The petition alleges bias and legal error favoring controversial Delta tunnel project
Sacramento County, San Joaquin County, the City of Stockton, Central Delta Water Agency, Sacramento County Water Agency, and Sacramento Area Sewer District (Petitioners) have sued the Delta Stewardship Council (Council) in Sacramento County Superior Court. The new suit seeks to invalidate a January 2025 Council decision regarding the controversial Delta Tunnel that also has broad consequences for other actions under the 2009 Delta Reform Act (Act). The Delta and its communities, the public interest requiring agency compliance with the Act, and the integrity and reputation of the Council all would suffer if the decision is allowed to stand.
The case arises out of a 2024 lawsuit challenging the California Department of Water Resources’ (DWR) Delta Conveyance Project (DCP or Delta Tunnel). In May 2024, the trial court stopped DWR from proceeding with geotechnical activities that DWR admitted were a key component of the Delta Tunnel project. DWR has admitted the Delta Tunnel is a “covered action” under the Act. Under the Act, a project proponent may not implement a covered action before certifying the whole project is consistent with the Delta Plan adopted by the Council. DWR had not done so.
After the trial court issued a preliminary injunction preventing DWR from undertaking the geotechnical activities, DWR attempted to sidestep the court’s ruling by submitting a smaller part of DCP geotechnical activities to the Council. In doing so, DWR asserted that the activities were not a covered action. The Petitioners, along with other Delta public agencies, tribes and environmental organizations, challenged DWR’s attempt to carve off a part of the DCP and bypass the Act’s requirements. In January 2025, the Council agreed there was no covered action, and thus it lacked jurisdiction in the matter. The Council nevertheless issued a 32-page decision that blessed DWR’s desire to chop the DCP into smaller pieces to avoid regulatory oversight.
In the new lawsuit, Petitioners accuse the Council of abusing its discretion and engaging in a biased and results-oriented process in favor of the controversial Delta Tunnel. The Council’s bias was confirmed by the fact that a Council staff member who participated in the certification appeal had previously filed a declaration supporting DWR’s opposition to the preliminary injunction in the trial court, and by the Council’s decision to issue a lengthy decision interpreting the Act in DWR’s favor despite having no jurisdiction to do so. Moreover, neither DWR nor the Council disclosed their communications concerning the Delta Tunnel and the geotechnical activities in private “early consultation” meetings preceding the Council’s decision. The Council staff’s presentations at the hearings also were skewed in favor of DWR’s position.
In addition to invalidating the Council’s decision on the DCP geotechnical activities, the lawsuit seeks a court decision confirming the Act prohibits “piecemealing” of covered actions for certification.
SEE ALSO:
The Council’s web page regarding the appeals that are the subject of the lawsuit is here: Geotech Appeals
Contacts:
Kelley Taber, Sacramento County, City of Stockton, Sacramento County Water Agency, and Sacramento Area Sewer District, ktaber@somachlaw.com
Osha Meserve, San Joaquin County and Central Delta Water Agency, osha@semlawyers.com
PRIOR COVERAGE ON MAVEN’S NOTEBOOK
DELTA COUNCIL: Appeals filed for the Delta Conveyance Project revised Certification of Consistency with the Delta Plan on remanded items
From the Delta Stewardship Council: The following parties have appealed the California Department of Water Resources’ Delta Conveyance Project Revised Certification of Consistency with the Delta Plan on Remanded Items (C20262), which was submitted to the Delta Stewardship Council on July 24, 2026. C20262-A1 – Sacramento Area Sewer District C20262-A2 – Twin Cities Group (Frank Loretz, Duane Martin, Kevin Young, David Schultz) C20262-A3 – County of San Joaquin, County of Solano, County of Yolo, Central Delta Water Agency, and Local Agencies of the North […]
DWR Submits the Delta Conveyance Project Revised Certification of Consistency on Remanded Items
From the Department of Water Resources: DWR submitted the Delta Conveyance Project Revised Certification of Consistency with the Delta Plan on Remanded Items on July 24, 2026. The Council’s determination on April 23, 2026, dismissed or denied the vast majority of appeals. For two policy areas, the Council directed a limited remand to DWR. Remands are a standard part of the Delta Reform Act’s Certification of Consistency and appeals process and provide an opportunity to supplement or clarify portions of the record to […]
DELTA CONVEYANCE PROJECT: Notice of intent to submit Delta Conveyance Project revised certification of consistency with the Delta Plan on remanded items
From the Department of Water Resources: This notice serves to inform all interested parties that the California Department of Water Resources intends to submit to the Delta Stewardship Council the Delta Conveyance Project Revised Certification of Consistency on Remanded Items. The Council’s determination on April 23, 2026, dismissed or denied the vast majority of appeals. For two policy areas, the Council directed a limited remand to DWR. Remands are a standard part of the Delta Reform Act’s Certification of Consistency […]
DELTA STEWARDSHIP COUNCIL votes 6-1 to remand the Delta Conveyance Project back to the Department of Water Resources (DWR)
Press release from the Delta Stewardship Council: On April 23, 2026, the Council voted to remand the project on two Delta Plan policies. The Council denied all other appeals raised by ten separate appellant groups. Before proceeding with the project, the DWR must file a new certification of consistency addressing: 1) the improvement of habitat conditions for the nonnative invasive golden mussel, and 2) potential conflicts involving the Conveyance Project’s Twin Cities Complex and Sac Sewer’s Harvest Water program, addressing […]
OFFICE OF THE GOVERNOR: Delta Conveyance Project achieves important milestone, advances closer to construction
California’s keystone water infrastructure project, the Delta Conveyance Project, marked an important milestone and forward progress towards full permitting. From the Office of the Governor: Yesterday, Governor Newsom’s Delta Conveyance Project achieved an important milestone: the Delta Stewardship Council decisively backed the project’s certification of consistency, an important step towards final permitting. The certification, which was submitted by the Department of Water Resources last October, demonstrates that the project meets key requirements of the Delta Reform Act and the Delta […]
STATE WATER CONTRACTORS applaud the Delta Stewardship Council’s vote of Delta Plan consistency for the Delta Conveyance Project
The Delta Conveyance Project is the state’s most important climate adaptation project, protecting the future for more than two-thirds of the state’s population Press release from the State Water Contractors: On Thursday, the Delta Stewardship Council (DSC) voted to accept staff recommendations regarding the Department of Water Resources (DWR)’s Certification of Consistency filing for the Delta Conveyance Project, confirming, with conditions, the Project’s consistency with the Delta Plan. “The State Water Contractors strongly support the Department of Water Resources’ certification […]
COURTHOUSE NEWS: California Delta tunnel project gets partial green light
The Delta Stewardship Council denied appeals to the conveyance project, but remanded two issues to the Department of Water Resources — meaning the project won’t proceed immediately. By Alan Riquelmy, Courthouse News Service Opponents of the Delta Conveyance Project said Thursday they had only days to read a 200-page draft decision that, if approved, would destroy their way of life. They stood before the Delta Stewardship Council, asking for more time before it opted to deny their appeals — a […]
DELTA CONVEYANCE PROJECT: DWR: Delta Stewardship Council determination affirms record; Limited remand to clarify two areas
Statement from the Department of Water Resources: The Department of Water Resources (DWR) appreciates the careful and thorough review conducted by the Delta Stewardship Council regarding appeals of the Delta Conveyance Project’s Certification of Consistency with the Delta Plan. The Council’s determination affirms the strength of the extensive evidentiary record supporting the project’s consistency with the Delta Plan. As DWR anticipated, the Council dismissed or denied the vast majority of the appeals. Today’s Council determination is an important step forward for the […]
RESTORE THE DELTA: Tribal and environmental advocates denounce Certification of Consistency approval for the Delta Conveyance Project
Groups warn the project ignores state law, threatens important Tribal cultural sites and the health of the Delta ecosystem. Press release from Restore the Delta: A coalition of tribes and environmental advocates expressed sharp criticism following the Delta Stewardship Council’s approval of the California Department of Water Resources (DWR) Certification of Consistency for the proposed Delta Conveyance Project (DCP). The coalition argues that the project violates state law and poses an imminent threat to Delta communities, its ecosystem and cultural […]
COURTHOUSE NEWS: Proposed decision favors California in Delta tunnel project dispute
A vote on the draft decision is expected Thursday at the Delta Stewardship Council meeting. By Alan Riquelmy, Courthouse News Service A draft decision issued Monday on appeals to California’s Delta Conveyance Project appears to hand the state a major win in its battle to make the massive project a reality. However, while discarding most of the appeals against the project, the recommendation to the Delta Stewardship Council calls for sending two issues about the project back to the state […]
