The petition alleges bias and legal error favoring controversial Delta tunnel project
Sacramento County, San Joaquin County, the City of Stockton, Central Delta Water Agency, Sacramento County Water Agency, and Sacramento Area Sewer District (Petitioners) have sued the Delta Stewardship Council (Council) in Sacramento County Superior Court. The new suit seeks to invalidate a January 2025 Council decision regarding the controversial Delta Tunnel that also has broad consequences for other actions under the 2009 Delta Reform Act (Act). The Delta and its communities, the public interest requiring agency compliance with the Act, and the integrity and reputation of the Council all would suffer if the decision is allowed to stand.
The case arises out of a 2024 lawsuit challenging the California Department of Water Resources’ (DWR) Delta Conveyance Project (DCP or Delta Tunnel). In May 2024, the trial court stopped DWR from proceeding with geotechnical activities that DWR admitted were a key component of the Delta Tunnel project. DWR has admitted the Delta Tunnel is a “covered action” under the Act. Under the Act, a project proponent may not implement a covered action before certifying the whole project is consistent with the Delta Plan adopted by the Council. DWR had not done so.
After the trial court issued a preliminary injunction preventing DWR from undertaking the geotechnical activities, DWR attempted to sidestep the court’s ruling by submitting a smaller part of DCP geotechnical activities to the Council. In doing so, DWR asserted that the activities were not a covered action. The Petitioners, along with other Delta public agencies, tribes and environmental organizations, challenged DWR’s attempt to carve off a part of the DCP and bypass the Act’s requirements. In January 2025, the Council agreed there was no covered action, and thus it lacked jurisdiction in the matter. The Council nevertheless issued a 32-page decision that blessed DWR’s desire to chop the DCP into smaller pieces to avoid regulatory oversight.
In the new lawsuit, Petitioners accuse the Council of abusing its discretion and engaging in a biased and results-oriented process in favor of the controversial Delta Tunnel. The Council’s bias was confirmed by the fact that a Council staff member who participated in the certification appeal had previously filed a declaration supporting DWR’s opposition to the preliminary injunction in the trial court, and by the Council’s decision to issue a lengthy decision interpreting the Act in DWR’s favor despite having no jurisdiction to do so. Moreover, neither DWR nor the Council disclosed their communications concerning the Delta Tunnel and the geotechnical activities in private “early consultation” meetings preceding the Council’s decision. The Council staff’s presentations at the hearings also were skewed in favor of DWR’s position.
In addition to invalidating the Council’s decision on the DCP geotechnical activities, the lawsuit seeks a court decision confirming the Act prohibits “piecemealing” of covered actions for certification.
25.02.24 Petn Compl FILEDSEE ALSO:
The Council’s web page regarding the appeals that are the subject of the lawsuit is here: Geotech Appeals
Contacts:
Kelley Taber, Sacramento County, City of Stockton, Sacramento County Water Agency, and Sacramento Area Sewer District, ktaber@somachlaw.com
Osha Meserve, San Joaquin County and Central Delta Water Agency, osha@semlawyers.com
PRIOR COVERAGE ON MAVEN’S NOTEBOOK
DWR: The Delta Stewardship Council affirms that DWR’s planned geotechnical investigations are not within their jurisdiction and are not a Covered Action
From the Department of Water Resources: Today the Delta Stewardship Council (DSC) affirmed that the Department of Water Resources’ (DWR) planned geotechnical investigations are not a “Covered Action” under the Delta Reform Act. Therefore, the DSC dismissed all appeals on the grounds that it does not have jurisdiction over these planned geotechnical activities. In order to come to that conclusion, the DSC considered whether project proponents can consider portions of a project in the Delta Plan consistency process. In consideration of the scope of the 2024-2026 Proposed Geotechnical Activities, the DSC found that DWR was […]
NOTEBOOK FEATURE: Delta Stewardship Council set to dismiss appeal of Delta Conveyance Project geotechnical activities
The Delta Stewardship Council released a draft decision last Friday dismissing the appeal from several NGOs, Tribes, and Delta water agencies against DWR’s certification of consistency with the Delta Plan for the Delta Conveyance Project. The draft decision will be discussed and possibly adopted at the Council’s meeting on Thursday. Background The 2009 Delta Reform Act created the Delta Stewardship Council and charged the Council with preparing a long-term management plan (the Delta Plan) for achieving the coequal goals of […]
COMMENTARY: Delaying the Delta Conveyance Project puts California’s water security at risk
By Jennifer Pierre, General Manager of the State Water Contractors The State Water Project, a cornerstone of California’s water delivery system, runs on 1960s-era infrastructure. This aging system is increasingly vulnerable to climate change, seismic risks and environmental challenges. Modernizing it with the Delta Conveyance Project (DCP) is essential to ensure sustainable and reliable access to the water that powers our state’s communities, farms and industries. That’s why recent attempts to delay progress on the DCP before the Delta Stewardship […]
DELTA CONVEYANCE PROJECT: Public hearing for appeal of DWR’s consistency determination for geotechnical activities scheduled for December 19
In October, the Department of Water Resources (DWR) filed a certification of consistency with the Delta Plan for the geotechnical activities associated with the Delta Conveyance Project. The draft certification only concerns certain geotechnical activities related to data collection (cone penetration tests, soil borings, and water quality sampling within soil borings), and not for the project in its entirety. Four appeals by about eighteen local agencies, conservation groups and Tribes were filed before the deadline. The Delta Stewardship Council has […]
NOTEBOOK FEATURE: Numerous appeals filed for DWR’s consistency determination for the Delta Conveyance Project geotechnical activities
The appeals allege numerous inconsistencies with Delta Plan policies and say piecemealing the project is inconsistent with CEQA Last Friday, the Delta Stewardship Council reported that four appeals had been filed for the Department of Water Resources (DWR) certification of consistency with the Delta Plan for the geotechnical activities associated with the Delta Conveyance Project. The draft certification only concerns certain geotechnical activities related to data collection (cone penetration tests, soil borings, and water quality sampling within soil borings), and […]
DELTA STEWARDSHIP COUNCIL: Certification of Consistency filed for Delta Conveyance Project geotechnical activities
From the Delta Stewardship Council: The following certification of consistency with the Delta Plan for a covered action has been submitted to the Delta Stewardship Council. Certification Number: C20242 Covered Action Title: 2024-2026 Proposed Geotechnical Activities Certifying Agency: California Department of Water Resources Certification Date: 10/08/2024 The certification of consistency and associated documents are available for public viewing on the Council’s online portal, alongside information on the Delta Reform Act and the Delta Plan covered actions process. Notes Regarding Appeals (1) Any person who […]
DELTA CONVEYANCE PROJECT: 2024 – 2026 Proposed Geotechnical Activities Delta Plan Consistency
From the Department of Water Resources: In compliance with the Delta Reform Act and Delta Stewardship Council regulatory process, the Department of Water Resources (DWR) is posting a draft certification of consistency for the 2024-2026 Proposed Geotechnical Activities proposed action at least 10-days prior to formal submission. This draft certification only concerns certain geotechnical activities related to data collection (cone penetration tests, soil borings, and water quality sampling within soil borings). Planning and design geotechnical data collection from the 2024-2026 […]
NOTICE of Certification of Consistency Filed: Central Valley Flood Protection Plan (CVFPP)
From the Delta Stewardship Council: The following certification of consistency with the Delta Plan for a covered action has been submitted to the Delta Stewardship Council. Certification Number: C20234 Covered Action Title: Central Valley Flood Protection Plan (CVFPP) Certifying Agency: Department of Water Resources Certification Date: 07/31/2023 The certification of consistency and associated documents are available for public viewing on the Council’s online portal alongside information on the Delta Reform Act and the Delta Plan covered actions process. Notes regarding appeals: (1) Any […]
DELTA COUNCIL: Certification of Consistency filed for the Ulatis Creek Habitat Restoration Project
From the Delta Stewardship Council: The Solano Resource Conservation District has submitted a certification of consistency to the Delta Stewardship Council for the Ulatis Creek Habitat Restoration Project. The certification of consistency and associated documents are available on the Council’s online portal. The public review and appeal period begins 7/8/2023 through 8/7/2023. Notes Regarding Appeals (1) Any person who claims that this covered action is inconsistent with the Delta Plan and, as a result of that inconsistency, that action will […]
DELTA STEWARDSHIP COUNCIL: Certification of consistency filed for Prospect Island Tidal Habitat Restoration Project
From the Delta Stewardship Council: The Department of Water Resources has filed a certification of consistency with the Delta Plan for the Propect Island Tidal Habitat Restoration Project. The certification of consistency and associated documents are available on the Council’s online portal. The public review and appeal period begins 5/30/2023 through 6/29/2023. Notes Regarding Appeals (1) Any person who claims that this covered action is inconsistent with the Delta Plan and, as a result of that inconsistency, that action will […]
