Wave-eroded marsh scarp of Whale's Tail South marsh in Eden Landing Ecological Reserve, Hayward, CA at low tide, looking south.

USGS: Study finds seasonal differences in marshland erosion in South San Francisco Bay

By the USGS Pacific Coastal and Marine Science Center

Erosion of marsh boundaries by waves is a major cause of marsh loss, but little research has captured the effect of seasonal differences on marsh-edge retreat. A new study conducted by scientists at the United States Geological Survey (USGS) and the University of California, Berkeley, shows how seasonal climate variations influence the rate of marshland erosion due to wind-driven wave activity.

The study, published in the Journal of Geophysical Research: Earth Surface, focused on Whale’s Tail Marsh South in South San Francisco Bay. The researchers constructed five detailed 3D models of the marsh surface using aerial photos collected with a fixed-wing aircraft and photogrammetry techniques, capturing its state during summer, fall, winter, and spring over a single year. By comparing these models, they observed distinct variations in marsh loss depending on the season:

  • Spring and Summer: The rate of marsh loss was notably high during these seasons, characterized by strong daily winds. The constant wave action generated by these winds led to accelerated erosion at the marsh boundaries.
  • Fall and Winter: In contrast, during the stormier fall and winter months, the rate of marsh loss was considerably slower. Despite the presence of storms, the absence of persistent daily winds resulted in less erosive wave activity.

Interestingly, the researchers also detected some positive changes during the fall and winter, with minor additions to the nearby mudflats. This suggests that under certain conditions, sediment deposition can occur, partially offsetting erosional losses.

When comparing the annual marsh loss data to historical data from 2004 to 2019, the researchers found a consistent pattern, indicating that their one-year study accurately reflected long-term marsh dynamics.

As climate change continues to impact coastal regions worldwide, understanding these seasonal variations will be essential for safeguarding marshland ecosystems, which are vital for coastal protection, biodiversity, and carbon sequestration.

Aerial orthomosaic photo of Whale’s Tail Marsh south (WTMS) in May 2022 with marsh-edge boundary drawn in orange at elevation of the scarp head contour. The green line is the location of an example cross-sectional transect (shown in Figure 2), but is artificially lengthened for legibility. (b) Map of South San Francisco Bay, with red indicating the location of WTMS and blue indicating location of the NOAA Redwood City Tide Gauge and Met Station. The black arrow is aligned with the most common wind direction during spring and summer seasons. (c) Photograph from atop the marsh surface on 19 May 2021 11:58 a.m. PDT, showing the relationship between high-marsh platform, steep scarp edge, crenulated coastline, and fronting mudflats. The photo was taken approximately 50 m south of the green transect in panel (a), facing southwards. Graphic by USGS.