New operating rules for massive Delta systems will increase water deliveries to Southern California cities and some growers. Salmon numbers could drop, especially in dry years.
By Alastair Bland, Cal Matters
State and federal water officials announced today their long-awaited new rules for operating two massive water delivery systems that serve 30 million Californians and much of the state’s farmland.
The rules will oversee operations of the State Water Project and the federal Central Valley Project, which carry water from Northern California rivers south to San Joaquin Valley farmers, Los Angeles area residents and many other water users in the southern half of the state.
Deliveries will increase for major urban water suppliers and many farms, while they’ll be cut for some farmers. Schedules for releasing water from Lake Shasta, the state’s largest reservoir, will be revised.
Chuck Bonham, director of the California Department of Fish and Wildlife, said the new rules represent the best path forward for the competing interests of cities, farms and fish. “It’s good for both people and the environment,” he said. “It’s the expression of what people want from us.”
The regulations, which take effect immediately, replace a set last modified in 2019 through a contentious revision by the first Trump administration, which state officials protested because it was expected to harm salmon and other Delta fish.
But environmental groups say the rules from the Biden and Newsom administrations are even worse than the Trump policy in terms of protecting the state’s iconic Chinook salmon, endangered Delta smelt and other fish.
A federal environmental review last month concluded that some salmon, which already are in dire shape, would be harmed by the new operating plan, with numbers of young salmon expected to drop.
“I’m concerned that the alternative adopted today will adversely harm fish that are already in danger of extinction,” said Ashley Overhouse, water policy advisor at Defenders of Wildlife.
Many farm groups and urban water districts applauded the new path forward, commending it as the best of several alternatives analyzed by state and federal officials for maintaining water supplies while protecting the environment.
For a consortium of water suppliers representing 27 million people in much of California, stretching from the Bay Area to San Diego, and 750,000 acres of farmland, the new plan is particularly beneficial. The rules will slightly increase their average annual deliveries of Delta water and, in drought years, cause no significant change. That includes the giant Metropolitan Water District, which provides much of the water used by 19 million Southern Californians in six counties.
But for some San Joaquin Valley farmers, water deliveries could drop by almost 20% in dry years, with slighter cuts in wetter years. Still, they have voiced their support for what they consider a plan that is overall protective of water supply.
The new plan comes as a disappointment for the Westlands Water District, the nation’s largest agricultural water supplier, which provides water for crops in Fresno and Kings counties. Growers there will lose some of their water, which district officials said has a disproportionate impact on their region.
“This inequity alone provides ample justification for” rejecting the new rules, the Westlands district wrote in a public comment last month. “It overlooks broader economic ripple effects, particularly on businesses dependent on agricultural workers.”
The federal and state agencies rejected another alternative, drafted with environmental groups, that would have sharply cut water exports. Average river flows through the Delta and into the ocean would have increased, improving river conditions and increasing fish populations, according to modeling by the Bureau of Reclamation.
No one knows what President-elect Donald Trump will do about the Delta rules when he enters the White House, but he has complained frequently about California “wasting water” by sending it into rivers and the ocean for fish.
In September, while campaigning in Southern California, Trump said he would turn on a giant “faucet” and promised Californians “more water than you ever saw and the smelt is not making it anyway…All those fields that are right now barren, the farmers would have all the water they needed.”
The two massive Central Valley water systems — operated by the California Department of Water Resources and the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation — have long formed the nexus of disagreements between water supply advocates and environmentalists, who fault them for devastating the region’s ecosystem.
According to an analysis released by the Bureau of Reclamation in November, the new rules will harm several protected species of fish. More cold water will be kept in Lake Shasta and released in the summer and fall as salmon spawn, resulting in more fish being born. But it fails the fish in subsequent life stages, ultimately leading to fewer juveniles, according to the federal agency’s report.
In critically dry years, winter-run Chinook could produce 23% fewer juveniles than baseline conditions — which are already tipping the fish toward extinction. Even in wet years, the modeling shows, winter-run juvenile salmon numbers will decline.
But while some fish would be harmed, two federal agencies responsible for protecting the species said the new operating rules are “not likely to jeopardize (their) continued existence.” If the agencies had found “jeopardy” of extinction, it would have triggered a protracted and complex federal process under the Endangered Species Act.
The new rules do not end the decades-long wars over Delta management or determine its entire fate. While they specifically cover operation of the two water delivery systems, they are just one part of the state’s broader Bay-Delta Water Quality Control Plan, an overarching state regulation now undergoing a separate, controversial update process.
Sometime in the next year, the state water board will vote on a new water-quality plan that would either impose rules that dramatically increase minimum flow requirements through the Delta or adopt a set of so-called voluntary agreements that commit water users to restoring stream habitat for salmon and other fish.
Also posted today …
- Reclamation greenlights action plan for the long-term operation of the Central Valley Project and State Water Project. press release from the Bureau of Reclamation
- New federal actions will help California better manage water supply, press release from Governor Newsom
More coverage of biological opinions …
PRESS RELEASE: Sites Reservoir advances toward construction with key permitting and contracting milestones
From the Sites Project Authority Today, the Sites Project Authority (Authority) announced two major advancements that move the Sites Reservoir Project (Project) closer to construction. Significant contractor outreach progress and two key environmental permitting milestones indicate that the Authority’s goal of breaking ground on Sites Reservoir by the end of 2026 is within reach. The Authority is reviewing a short list of qualified applicants for the Construction Manager at Risk (CMAR) contract to construct the reservoir and roads portion of […]
DWR: Changes to Delta operations start today: Balancing water needs for millions of Californians and the environment
From the Department of Water Resources: California’s water system is complex and requires real-time adjustments to balance the needs of our state’s cities and farms and the natural environment. Starting today, the State Water Project (SWP) is adjusting operations to meet those needs. The SWP’s pumping plant near Tracy diverts water from the Sacramento and San Joaquin rivers and lifts it into canals that flow to reservoirs and local water agencies. In March, the pumps moved approximately 125,000 acre-feet of […]
WHITE HOUSE: Trump issues broad Executive Order targeting CA water policy; Stakeholders, enviro groups respond
President Trump’s Executive Order By the authority vested in me as President by the Constitution and the laws of the United States of America, it is hereby ordered: Section 1. Policy. For weeks, residents of the Los Angeles area have watched raging fires consume their homes, belongings, beloved pets, and childhood memories. Almost immediately, firefighters were unable to fight the blaze due to dry hydrants, empty reservoirs, and inadequate water infrastructure. Today, at least 28 people have lost their lives […]
CAL MATTERS: Trump orders more Central Valley water deliveries — claiming it would help LA fires
Citing the LA fires, Trump directed federal agencies to “immediately take actions to override” water operations and environmental rules. But the water mostly serves Central Valley farms. By Alastair Bland, Cal Matters President Donald Trump signed a sweeping executive order Sunday that told federal agencies to “immediately take action” to deliver more Central Valley water and eliminate rules that stand in the way, including endangered species protections. In the new order, Trump cited the Los Angeles fires, even though the […]
CAL MATTERS: Trump takes step to overhaul Delta water deliveries to farms, cities
Trump apparently wants to override new Biden-Newsom rules that have widespread support among Southern California cities and some Central Valley farmers. By Alastair Bland, Cal Matters Stay up-to-date with free briefings on topics that matter to all Californians. Subscribe to CalMatters today for nonprofit news in your inbox. President Donald Trump lost no time Monday in advancing his agenda for California’s water supply with a “presidential action” intended to send more Delta water south to millions of Southern Californians and […]
DWR NEWS: State Water Project operations: New framework already benefiting California’s water supply
From the Department of Water Resources: What’s New: In December 2024, a new framework took effect to minimize harm to endangered species from the operation of California’s two biggest water projects. The framework, developed by federal fishery agencies and called a “biological opinion,” replaces a framework that had been in place since 2019. How It Helps the State Water Project: The new science and additional flexibility that underpin the revised framework allow water project operators to respond more nimbly to […]
GOVERNOR NEWSOM: California pumping more water now than under Trump Administration
From Office of the Governor: What you need to know: California has worked with the federal government to manage water delivery and increase the amount of water flowing to our farmers and southern regions – even when federal and state law require pumps to be slowed down. Despite recent misinformation, California is delivering more water to farmers and Southern regions of the state than under the Trump Administration. Thanks to strategic negotiations with the Biden administration, California has worked with the federal […]
THE CENTER SQUARE: Newsom, Biden unveil new water plan amid drought, fish protection debate
By Madeline Armstrong, The Center Square California Gov. Gavin Newsom and the Biden-Harris Administration reached a long-awaited agreement on the updated rules for the State Water Project (SWP) and the Central Valley Project (CVP), which transfer water from Northern California to other parts of the state, supplying water to millions of Californians. “The completion of new operating rules for the Central Valley Project is the cornerstone of our efforts to address record drought and changing climate conditions in California,” said […]
CAL MATTERS: Biden, Newsom officials announce long-awaited new water delivery rules
New operating rules for massive Delta systems will increase water deliveries to Southern California cities and some growers. Salmon numbers could drop, especially in dry years. By Alastair Bland, Cal Matters Welcome to CalMatters, the only nonprofit newsroom devoted solely to covering issues that affect all Californians. Sign up for WhatMatters to receive the latest news and commentary on the most important issues in the Golden State. State and federal water officials announced today their long-awaited new rules for operating two massive […]
USBR: Reclamation greenlights action plan for the long-term operation of the Central Valley Project and State Water Project
From the Bureau of Reclamation: The Bureau of Reclamation today approved a new plan for the Long-Term Operation of the Central Valley Project and Delta facilities of the State Water Project. The plan presents a path forward with more predictable actions for endangered fish species and a more reliable CVP response to multi-year droughts. “The resilience of the Central Valley Project, with its importance to the agricultural industry and drinking water deliveries across California, is critical to the state’s water supply […]
