MORNING NEWS FLASH … NGOs send letter to Governor Brown on Phase 1 settlement agreements; SF, Delta residents protest at Senator Feinstein’s San Francisco office

NGOs send letter to Governor Brown regarding Phase 1 voluntary settlements

“Settlement content shared with us to date is insufficient to meet legal obligations or protect fish and wildlife,” the letter states

American Rivers, Defenders of Wildlife, Environmental Defense Fund, The Nature Conservancy, and Trout Unlimited have sent a letter to Governor Brown regarding the voluntary settlement agreement negotiations for Phase 1 of the Bay-Delta Water Quality Control Plan.

The letter notes the significant efforts over the past two years to negotiate a voluntary settlement agreement.  “Some progress has been made; however, the settlement content shared with us to date is insufficient to meet legal obligations or protect fish and wildlife. Accordingly, we believe it is imperative that the Board approve the proposal for Phase 1 at its hearing on December 12th,” the letter states.

We have expressed a willingness to evaluate different combinations of flow and habitat provided they have a scientific basis and meet the Plan objectives. However,
negotiations have not made enough progress toward agreements that could gain our support or legally be accepted by the Board.”

Read the full text of the letter here:  12.6.18 NGO Letter to Gov Brown re VSA

SF Bay Delta Residents Protest Sen Feinstein’s Water Deal

From Restore the Delta and Food and Water Watch:

Public interest groups, conservationists, fishermen, and SF Bay-Delta residents delivered a strong message at the San Francisco office of Senator Dianne Feinstein today, “Drop Your Support for the WIIN Act!”

The protesters came from across Northern California to protest Feinstein’s proposed Water Infrastructure Improvement Act for the Nation (WIIN) deal with the Trump Administration and Republican leader Kevin McCarthy. The last-minute rider would be attached to the bill needed to prevent a government shutdown.

The Feinstein-McCarthy deal would extend a drought-era waiver of environmental protections for the SF Bay-Delta. When it was enacted, Feinstein promised the act would sunset after the drought in 2021. The rider would extend those provisions for another seven years, even as native fish species are going extinct.

Opposition to the WIIN Act rider grows

“Here’s a news flash for Brown and Feinstein. The drought is over. The extension only serves to hand the federal government more power over California water politics. It’s the means for Brown and Feinstein to force their will on the state.” The Mercury News, editorial 12/4/18

California Senator Kamala Harris joined the chorus of opposition to the WIIN Act on Wednesday, 12/5/18. “We must invest in sustainable water projects that protect critical ecosystems while also supporting our important agricultural economies across the state,” said Senator Harris. “Extending the controversial and detrimental policies of the WIIN Act is not the way to do this.”

At the rally in San Francisco, speakers gave testimony about the harms this deal would cause.

“We are very disappointed that Senator Feinstein is pushing a water deal that grossly favors corporate agribusiness at the expense of our rivers and water future,” said Adam Scow, California director of Food & Water Watch. “California needs real water solutions that protect the health of our rivers and bay while allowing for responsible agricultural production. The recent rapid expansion of corporate agribusiness in the driest parts of California is placing enormous stress on our precious water supply and is unsustainable.”

“Today is a very difficult day. We would honestly prefer to be doing just about anything rather than protesting against California’s Senior Senator who just won re-election,” said Barbara Barrigan-Parrilla, executive director of Restore the Delta. “But protest we must because the WIIN Act is a betrayal of the San Francisco Bay-Delta estuary, its communities, fisheries, salmon, wildlife, responsible California water management, Northern California Indian Tribes, Delta environmental justice communities, the public trust, the public good, and our faith that in the long run that Senator Feinstein would do the right thing.

“This is the ultimate betrayal of California’s environment and people. We urge Senator Feinstein to stop the WIIN Act from advancing and return California water management to the rule of law — to the norms and customs of regular government processes — and to uphold all that she claims to value.”


Food & Water Watch champions healthy food and clean water for all. We stand up to corporations that put profits before people, and advocate for a democracy that improves people’s lives and protects our environment.

Restore the Delta fights for a Delta with waters that are fishable, swimmable, drinkable, and farmable, able to support the health of the estuary, San Francisco Bay, and the ocean beyond. Restore the Delta envisions the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta as a place where a vibrant local economy, tourism, recreation, farming, wildlife, and fisheries thrive as our waterway commons.




Sign up for daily email service and you’ll always be one of the first to know!

  • Sign up for daily emails and get all the Notebook’s aggregated and original water news content delivered to your email box by 9AM. Breaking news alerts like this one, too. Sign me up!

keeping watchMaven’s Notebook
constantly watching over the world of California water

Print Friendly, PDF & Email