Friday Flashbacks are a new weekly feature where I’ll dig into the archives and bring out some older posts that still have relevance today. In the fall of 2013, Emily DeMarco wrote a series of posts which examined Delta and California water issues through the eyes of North Delta Water Agency’s Melinda Terry, the NRDC’s Kate Poole, and the Department of Fish and Wildlife Director Chuck Bonham:
Original published date: October 23,2013
Melinda Terry had reached a breaking point. She set her jaw, gripped either side of the wooden podium, and lectured the Bay Delta Conservation Plan (BDCP) Finance Working Group in a voice laced with frustration and anger. Although known for bringing an emphatic but respectful, clear-eyed manner to the often heated conversations about the BDCP, this time Terry’s disappointment with the draft Statewide Economic Impact Study sharpened her tongue.
Discarding “sham” and “deceitful” as adjectives too charitable to describe the draft report, which estimates the statewide benefits of the proposed BDCP, she settled on “fraud” at the August 8th meeting. Her severe assessment comes from what she sees as the state’s continued failure to plainly communicate the true costs of the proposed tunnels on Delta communities. …
Original publish date: October 30, 2013
Through the red and white sandstone canyons of northwest Colorado flow two rivers, the Green and the Yampa. Their confluence is the heart of Dinosaur National Monument, and it was on their banks that Kate Poole, water attorney for the Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC), had her first exposure to both water management in the West and its hand maiden: controversy.
A Michigan native, Poole spent a summer after college working as a seasonal park ranger—a job she highly recommends—at the Monument. And she learned about the Echo Park Dam controversy that launched an era of environmental conservation. …
Last January, Chuck Bonham sat down in Siskiyou County with a group of residents—including ranchers, farmers, miners, water users, and conservationists—to talk about natural resources and wildlife management in the area. Right off the bat, the talk turned contentious as one resident expressed his frustration with what he saw as the California Department of Fish and Wildlife’s (CDFW) history of protecting the region’s salmon at the expense of its people.
In response, Bonham reached over, shook the man’s hand—the two had never met before—and told him a story.
During his first year as Director of CDFW, Bonham had judged a wildlife photography contest on the steps of the State Capitol. The photo that he selected showed two birds flying in opposite directions, each bird holding one end of the same fish in its talons. And Bonham identified with that fish, saying “that’s kinda what it feels like to be at the Department.” The tension in the room dissipated ever so slightly. …
Sign up for daily emails and get all the Notebook’s aggregated and original water news content delivered to your email box by 9AM. Breaking news alerts, too. Sign me up!